Privacy, Please! (Housing Decisions in Charlestown)

One month ago someone tagged me in the comments of a Facebook post about Springville Manor. The original post celebrated a widow’s acceptance of the City’s relocation program from Pleasant Ridge to Springville Manor, and also accused members of “the Association” (presumably the Pleasant Ridge Neighborhood Association) of harassing and bullying people like that widow who have made this choice. The person who tagged me asked me to investigate these accusations. I have spent the past month looking into the situation and I’d like to share what I’ve found.

I reached out to current residents of Springville Manor, people in the transition but who have not yet moved, and leaders of the Pleasant Ridge Neighborhood Association. First, let me say that the leaders of the Pleasant Ridge Neighborhood Association deny that they have harassed anyone about their decision to relocate. Their official position is that individuals have the right to make their own decisions and should do so based on their unique circumstances. If anyone who has chosen to remain in Pleasant Ridge has bullied folks who have decided to move it was NOT done by the hand of the PRNA.

Unfortunately, none of the current residents of Springville Manor nor those in transition are comfortable speaking on record. Some people never answered my request for an interview, others simply said that they don’t want to “cause any trouble” or become the subject of any form of “retribution.”

Has harassment or bullying occurred? My official answer is I don’t know. What I did find,  though not “harassment,” was far from encouraging.

In order to make my investigation as thorough as I could, I went to public Facebook posts  to see how people are talking about the relocation program. What I saw was discouraging to say the least. Negative comments about the Springville Manor houses are not hard to find. Some folks disparage the deal as a whole*, others express their distaste for the design of the houses. Words like “glorified garages” and “concentration camp” were found on posts. I imagine that for people who now or soon will own these houses, such statements are hurtful and cruel.

But before we jump on these statements as proof of harassment, it should be noted that for every negative post about the homes in Springville Manor, I found numerous hateful comments about the homes in Pleasant Ridge as well. How many years have the folks on the hill been subjected to the same scrutiny regardless of the actual condition of their homes?

Private-PropertyHere’s the crux of it: The choice to move is a PERSONAL DECISIONbased on individual circumstances that are NONE of our business. It’s sad that Charlestown has become so divided over issues of personal property rights. Do you live in Pleasant Ridge in a home that you want to keep? Great! Have you decided to leave Pleasant Ridge for a home in Springville Manor? Wonderful! Do you live elsewhere? Then it’s not your decision. May we all vow to keep better check on the words we use in public and be sensitive to how they might be interpreted by others.  

You don’t have to like the house in which I live and I don’t have to approve of your sense of style. It’s that simple. I sincerely hope that soon Charlestown can heal from the division that has evolved in the past few years. We’re a great group of people who just want to live, and work, and raise our families in small town Indiana. Here’s hoping we can keep Charlestown First.

*The deal works this way: Springville Manor homes are priced at $65,000 for people in Pleasant Ridge who own their homes. The redevelopment company (Neace) pays $10,000 for the Pleasant Ridge home, regardless of the condition of the house. The City provides a forgivable $20,000 loan (the new owner must live in the home for three years and other provisions are in place for death or nursing home placement). The new owner then assumes a $35,000 mortgage that accrues simple interest for the time they live in the home with all mortgage payments suppressed for the duration. Upon their death or move, the heirs or person responsible becomes liable to repay the $35,000 + interest.

Author: Treva Hodges

Resident of Charlestown, Indiana. Advocate.

2 thoughts on “Privacy, Please! (Housing Decisions in Charlestown)”

  1. Who is carrying the mortgages? A bank of a private investor. Living in the home for 20 years would push the balance due to over $55,000 at 5% interest. Which is not a bad deal for a buyer in 20 years for one of the units. Considering today it is selling for $65,000. And they got to live in it for 20 years for $30,000 invested byHampton/Neace and the City.

    The bigger question is, where does the City get the $640,000.00 to pay for the 32 units at $20,000 each? Tax payers. How can I get $20,000 from the City to spend on my property? Or $1 million to build a road on my property? This Private-Government Partnership is call Fascism.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s